Quick View
$9.59 $11.99
Krumville Bake Shop's spin on classic Italian amaretti cookie marries deep chocolate and sweet almonds to...
Quick View
$1.99 $3.99
Malvi's Spiked Espresso Marshmallow Cookies combine an intense coffee flavored marshmallow with deep, dark chocolate cookies...
Quick View
$7.99
Crumbly cookie and tart raspberry jam (from Maya's Jams!) come together to make this delicious...
Quick View
$4.50
Salt of the Earth Bakery's "The Mayan" is dense, fudge-y and rich brownie with a...
Quick View
$14.99
White Lion Baking Company's gluten-free cookies are baked with almond flour and sweetened with organic...
Quick View
$11.99
Crack Cookies were given their name for two simple reasons: 1) They are made from...
Quick View
$9.99
Farm Animals to People! Take a bite of these 42% milk chocolate covered organic animal...
Quick View
$13.99
This amazing mix of sweet and savory combines Legally Addictive's original Crack Cookie (cracker coated...
Quick View
$7.99
These crispy cookies are perfect for your afternoon tea! With freshly crushed cardamom, they impart...
Quick View
$6.99 $9.99
Brooklyn Brittle's Espresso Chip variety is the perfect way to polish off a satisfying meal....
Quick View
$9.95
Topped with crunchy pearlized sugar, these cookies are bursting with lemon flavor owing to the...
Quick View
$9.95
These are the kind of cookies, you'd make at home if you could! The espresso...
Quick View
$6.99 $9.99
This beautiful combination of sweet and savory is more like a shortbread than cracker. The...
Quick View
$7.99
Unna Bakery's Ginger Snaps are crisp, spicy rounds with pieces of sweet almonds are lovely...
Quick View
$11.99 $14.99
As a German in NYC, Sweet & Salzig founder Katja was missing her family's cakes and...
Quick View
$3.99
Fresh, pure peppermint and dark chocolate pair perfectly in this revitalizing treat that's perfect for...
Quick View
$30.00
This year's Cookie sampler is sure to make you smile. It includes Grey Ghost Bakery's Chocolate...
Quick View
$2.89
Sit back and reminisce about those after-school treats or early morning breakfasts of your youth...
Quick View
$9.99
These colorful Crack Cookies are an exciting addition to Legally Addictive’s line of part cracker/part...
Quick View
$35.00
Imagine the perfect cookie, it probably has a crisp and edge and a chewy moist...
Quick View
Out of Stock - $11.95
Crack Cookies were given their name for two simple reasons: 1) They are made from...
Quick View
Out of Stock - $3.99
Malvi's Salted Caramel Marshmallow Cookies are speckled with whole vanilla beans that add a classic...
Quick View
Out of Stock - $2.99 $3.99
Dark chocolate marshmallows bound to dark chocolate shortbread with...dark chocolate. It's a chocolate-lover's dream! With...
Quick View
Out of Stock - $60.00
There’s nothing more comforting than knowing you’re adequately stocked with this assortment of cookies—and more!— when a craving...
Quick View
Out of Stock - $4.50
For the brownie purist! Fair-trade Guittard chocolate is the main ingredient in these chewy bites...
Quick View
Out of Stock - $7.99
Unna Bakery's Vanilla Dream cookies have a light flavor of vanilla and are made with Baker's...
Quick View
Out of Stock - $2.89
Meg's personal favorite, this take on a childhood classic has a rich, chocolate filling inside...
Quick View
Out of Stock - $2.89
Recapture summer with every bite of these delightful strawberry tarts! Filled with strawberry jam and...